If you are a U.S. treaty resident receiving a genuine merit prize, seek Article 22 relief rather than assume the 25% Italian withholding is creditable.
“I am an Italian citizen and US tax resident living in Massachusetts. I am receiving a €1,333 merit prize for doctoral research from an Italian foundation. Should I pay $105 for Form 6166 to use the US-Italy tax treaty, or take a 25% Italian withholding and claim a foreign tax credit on Form 1116? If I take the withholding, is it creditable even though the treaty might have exempted it, and which treaty article applies to this prize?”
Summary
The quoted withholding would be €333.25, leaving €999.75, versus a $105 certificate-application fee before any other costs. If tax has already been withheld, Italy also provides a treaty-refund route.
For a genuine merit prize, your practical choice is usually between preventing Italian withholding and recovering it—not treating Form 1116 as an interchangeable substitute.
If this is a genuine award for achievement rather than compensation, Article 22(1) assigns the taxing right to your country of treaty residence. Have the foundation confirm that it will apply the exemption using Italy’s Form D and your U.S. residence evidence before paying the nonrefundable $105 Form 8802 fee to obtain Form 6166. This is the cleaner route if the foundation will implement it. (Treaty Article 22; Agenzia delle Entrate, nonresident treaty relief; Instructions for Form 8802.)
If the foundation has already taken , or will not grant relief at source, preserve the treaty claim through an Italian refund request. The deadline is 48 months from the withholding date, supported by residence certification and proof of the tax taken. (Agenzia delle Entrate, nonresident treaty refunds; Form D—Other Income.)
You cannot safely choose this as an automatic alternative. A generally does not cover tax exceeding your actual Italian liability after applying the treaty, even when it was withheld. A documented cost-and-remedy exception may change that result, but simply declining treaty paperwork does not establish it. (26 CFR 1.901-2(e)(5)(i).)
Article 22 relief assumes you are a U.S. treaty resident and the prize is not connected with an Italian permanent establishment or fixed base under Article 22(2).
Read the full explanationHide the full explanation
Watch out for
Next steps
Use this order to avoid paying for a certificate unnecessarily and to preserve your refund and reporting options.
Before paying the IRS fee
Establish the award category and arrange relief at source
Separate recognition of past achievement from educational support or compensation using the cases above. For the genuine-prize case, request written confirmation that the foundation will apply Article 22 relief using Form D and Form 6166. Italy permits direct treaty relief through the payer, but do not spend the nonrefundable certificate fee on the assumption that the foundation will implement it. The official procedure is https://www.agenziaentrate.gov.it/portale/Schede/Rimborsi/Convenzioni+contro+le+doppie+imposizioni/Soggetti+non+residenti+in+Italia/.
Requirements
At least 45 days before the certificate is needed
Request Form 6166 using Form 8802
Use the instructions at https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i8802. Pay through Pay.gov by searching “IRS Certs,” upload the Form 8802 copy required by the payment process, and enter the payment confirmation number on your application. Submit the completed application and attachments by fax to 877-824-9110 or 304-707-9792, or by mail to Department of the Treasury, Internal Revenue Service, Philadelphia, PA 19255-0625. The application requests Form 6166; paying the fee alone does not complete the residence-certification process.
Requirements
Before the foundation processes payment
Deliver Form D and the residence certificate
For the genuine-prize case, identify the United States as your treaty-residence country and Article 22 as the applicable article on Form D. Complete and sign the relevant exemption declarations, including beneficial ownership and the absence of a connected Italian permanent establishment or fixed base, only if true. Give the foundation Form D and the residence certificate under the relief-at-source arrangement established in step 1.
Requirements
Within 48 months of withholding
File an Italian refund request if tax is withheld
Send the treaty-refund request to Agenzia delle Entrate—Centro Operativo di Pescara, via Rio Sparto 21, 65129 Pescara, Italy. Include the residence evidence and documentation proving the tax taken. The 48-month period runs from the withholding date, not from your U.S. return filing date. Do not treat that potentially refundable amount as automatically eligible for Form 1116 while leaving the Italian remedy unused.
Requirements
For the year you receive the payment
Report the gross prize and evaluate any credit separately
For a genuine taxable merit prize, report the gross €1,333 converted to U.S. dollars—not just the €999.75 received after 25% withholding—in the prizes-and-awards category of your federal return. Publication 525 places that category on Schedule 1 of Form 1040. Ordinarily use the spot exchange rate when you receive the award. Claim Form 1116 only for tax that qualifies after the treaty, compulsory-payment rule, any documented exception, and the U.S. credit limitation have been applied. Do not claim a Massachusetts other-jurisdiction credit for Italian tax.
Requirements
Legal sources
This answer draws on the U.S.–Italy tax convention and Treasury explanation, Treasury regulations, IRS instructions, Italy’s Agenzia delle Entrate procedures, and Massachusetts Department of Revenue guidance.
U.S.–Italy Income Tax Convention, Article 22
A genuine prize not covered by a more specific article is generally taxable only in the recipient’s treaty-residence country.
Article 22(1); paragraph 2 contains the connected-business/fixed-base exception
Items of income of a resident of a Contracting State, wherever arising, not dealt with in the foregoing Articles of this Convention shall be taxable only in that State.
U.S.–Italy Income Tax Convention, Articles 20–21
The teacher/researcher and student provisions have specific eligibility and payment-purpose requirements; they are not generic exemptions for anything related to doctoral research.
Articles 20(1) and 21(1)
A professor or teacher who makes a temporary visit to a Contracting State for a period that is not expected to exceed two years for the purpose of teaching or conducting research at a university, college, school, or other recognized educational institution, or at a medical facility primarily funded from governmental sources, and who is, or immediately before such visit was, a resident of the other Contracting State shall, for a period not exceeding two years, be exempt from tax in the first-mentioned Contracting State in respect of remuneration from such teaching or research. Payments which a student or business apprentice (trainee) who is, or immediately before visiting a Contracting State was, a resident of the other Contracting State and who is present in the first-mentioned State exclusively for the purpose of his education at a recognized educational institution or training receives for the purpose of his maintenance, education, or training shall not be taxed in that State provided that such payments arise outside that State.
Treasury Technical Explanation, U.S.–Italy Convention
The student article’s protection against the saving clause depends on citizenship and permanent-resident status, not merely whether someone meets a domestic tax-residency test.
Explanation of Article 21
The saving clause of paragraph 2 of Article 1 (Personal Scope) does not apply to this Article with respect to an individual who is neither a citizen of the host State nor has been admitted for permanent residence there.
26 CFR 1.901-2(e)(5)(i)
Treaty-excess payments are ordinarily noncreditable, but the regulation expressly recognizes reasonable-cost and effective-remedy qualifications.
(e)(5)(i)
An amount remitted to a foreign country (a “foreign payment”) is not a compulsory payment, and thus is not an amount of foreign income tax paid, to the extent that the foreign payment exceeds the amount of liability for foreign income tax under the foreign tax law (as defined in paragraph (g) of this section). However, a taxpayer is not required to reduce its foreign income tax liability to the extent the reasonably expected, arm's length costs of reducing the liability would exceed the amount by which the liability could be reduced. An available remedy is considered effective and practical if an economically rational taxpayer would pursue it whether or not a compulsory payment of the amount at issue would be eligible for a U.S. foreign tax credit.
Instructions for Form 8802, revised October 2026
Form 8802 requests Form 6166, costs an individual $105, requires advance planning, and does not certify every condition for treaty eligibility.
User Fee; When To Apply; certification limitations; Where To Apply
The user fee for a request by an individual applicant is $105 per Form 8802, regardless of the number of countries for which certification is requested or the number of tax year(s) to which the certification applies. A Form 8802 application(s) will not be processed until the nonrefundable user fee is paid. You should mail your application, including full payment of the user fee, at least 45 days before the date you need to submit Form 6166. In order to claim a benefit under a tax treaty, there are other requirements in addition to residence.
Agenzia delle Entrate—Nonresident treaty relief
Italy allows requests for treaty relief at source and treaty refunds within 48 months of withholding.
Soggetti non residenti in Italia
I soggetti non residenti in Italia, possono presentare la richiesta di rimborso su modello, qualora esistente, o su semplice istanza al Centro Operativo di Pescara, entro il termine di decadenza di 48 mesi dalla data del prelevamento dell’imposta (articoli 37 e 38 del Dpr n. 602 del 1973). Gli interessati possono inoltre chiedere l’applicazione diretta della Convenzione al sostituto d’imposta italiano già in sede di effettuazione della ritenuta.
Agenzia delle Entrate, Form D—Other Income
Form D is Italy’s treaty-relief form for income categories without a dedicated form.
Form heading and exemption/refund declarations
FORM D – OTHER INCOME (this form must be used for the categories of income for which there is no specific form like employee income, self-employed income, capital gains, director’s fees, etc.).
Agenzia delle Entrate—Treaty refund procedure
The Italian treaty-refund request goes to the Revenue Agency’s Pescara office.
Rimborsi di imposta in base a convenzioni internazionali
Se avete diritto a un rimborso di imposta in base alle norme di una convenzione internazionale, non dovete chiederlo compilando questa dichiarazione ma presentando un'apposita domanda all'Agenzia delle Entrate - Centro Operativo di Pescara, via Rio Sparto, 21 - 65129 Pescara.
26 CFR 1.863-1(d)
A prize from a foreign payer is generally foreign-source, but payments for services follow different sourcing rules.
(d)(1) and (d)(2)(ii)
Scholarships, fellowship grants, grants, prizes and awards made by a foreign government (or an instrumentality, agency, or any political subdivision thereof), an international organization (as defined in section 7701(a)(18)), or a person other than a U.S. person (as defined in section 7701(a)(30)) shall be treated as income from sources without the United States. The provisions of this paragraph (d) do not apply to amounts paid as salary or other compensation for services.
U.S.–Italy Income Tax Convention, Article 23
The treaty does not promise dollar-for-dollar reimbursement of every Italian tax payment; U.S. credit limitations still apply.
Article 23(2)(a)
Such appropriate amount shall be based upon the amount of tax paid to Italy, but shall not exceed the limitations of the law of the United States (for the purpose of limiting the credit to the United States tax on income from sources without the United States).
IRS Publication 525, 2025 edition
A scientific merit prize is generally taxable in the United States, while qualified scholarships have separate exclusion rules.
Prizes and Awards; Scholarships and Fellowships
If you were awarded a prize in recognition of accomplishments in religious, charitable, scientific, artistic, educational, literary, or civic fields, you must generally include the value of the prize in your income. A candidate for a degree can exclude amounts received as a qualified scholarship or fellowship. Amounts used for room and board don’t qualify for the exclusion. Generally, you can’t exclude from your gross income the part of any scholarship or fellowship that represents payment for teaching, research, or other services required as a condition for receiving the scholarship.
IRS—Foreign currency conversion
Report the prize in dollars using the applicable exchange rate, ordinarily the spot rate when you receive it.
Translating foreign currency into U.S. dollars
You must express the amounts you report on your U.S. tax return in U.S. dollars. Therefore, you must translate foreign currency into U.S. dollars if you receive income or pay expenses in a foreign currency. In general, use the exchange rate prevailing (i.e., the spot rate) when you receive, pay or accrue the item.
Massachusetts DOR—Other Jurisdiction Credit
Massachusetts does not provide this credit for Italian income tax.
Credit exclusions
This credit is not allowed for: Taxes paid to a foreign country other than Canada or any of its provinces
These are the official rules as published or updated on the cited dates; rules and forms can change.
This is general information about official tax processes, not legal or personalized tax advice, and SettleKit is not a law firm.

